Sponsored by

How 2M+ Professionals Stay Ahead on AI

AI is moving fast and most people are falling behind. 

The Rundown AI keeps you ahead of the curve. 

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses — tailored to your needs.

Utah Republicans owe Judge Dianna Gibson a thank-you note.

GOP leaders have spent two years attacking her. She ruled the 2021 congressional map unconstitutional in the lawsuit over the Legislature’s repeal of the voter-approved independent redistricting commission. Last year they grew angrier when she rejected the Legislature’s proposed replacement and adopted the plaintiffs’ map instead.

Then came the 2026 blue wave. Under Gibson’s map, Democrats won one of Utah’s four seats. Ben McAdams carried the Salt Lake County district by 45 points, and Republicans won the other three by at least 7. On the maps the Legislature favored, the same ballots would have produced a much closer delegation.

Utah Political Watch laid the 2026 precinct-level results over the 2021 map and two maps the court did not choose. The analysis combines all Democratic and all Republican congressional candidates on the ballot in each precinct.

Map

CD1

CD2

CD3

CD4

Democratic-leaning seats

Court's map (used in 2026)

D+44.7

R+7.1

R+20.8

R+13.9

1

2021 Legislature map

D+2.8

D+3.0

R+1.0

R+2.6

2, narrowly

Legislature's Map C

R+7.2

D+17.3

D+16.6

R+26.6

2

Plaintiff Map 2

R+7.1

D+36.4

R+0.7

R+26.6

1, plus a toss-up

District numbers are specific to each map. CD1 on one map is not the same territory as CD1 on another.

The 2021 map: four toss-ups

The Legislature’s 2021 map split Salt Lake County four ways, pairing a slice of the county with a large Republican rural or suburban area in each district. Republicans won all four seats under it in 2022 and 2024.

In 2024, Donald Trump carried every one of those districts by at least 18 points. This year, all four landed within three points:

  • CD1: D+2.8 (Trump +19.5 in 2024)

  • CD2: D+3.0 (Trump +19.9)

  • CD3: R+1.0 (Trump +18.7)

  • CD4: R+2.6 (Trump +26.1)

The swing toward Democrats ran roughly 18 to 24 points in every district, enough to put all four in play.

Support Utah Political Watch
Readers like you keep this going.
Other amount

Option C: two comfortable Democratic seats

After Gibson struck down the 2021 map, the Legislature proposed five replacements. Republicans rallied behind Option C, which split Salt Lake County between two districts instead of four and divided only three counties: Salt Lake, Davis and Utah.

Trump won all four Option C districts in 2024, two of them narrowly: CD2 by 6.6 points and CD3 by 2.2. In 2026, both flipped decisively:

  • CD2 (west Salt Lake County and Tooele County): D+17.3

  • CD3 (east Salt Lake County, northern Utah County, Summit and Wasatch counties, and the rural east): D+16.6

  • CD1 (northern Utah): R+7.2

  • CD4 (central and southern Utah): R+26.6

In a year like 2026, a map built entirely of Trump-won districts would have given Democrats a second seat. The map the court chose did not.

Plaintiffs’ Map 2: one deep-blue seat and a toss-up

Gibson passed over this alternative from the plaintiffs, and it produced the closest district of any map. Trump carried Map 2’s CD3 by 19.2 points in 2024. This year Republicans led there by about 2,100 votes out of more than 281,000 cast. An 18.5-point swing turned a safe Republican seat into a coin flip.

The map’s CD2, meanwhile, went Democratic by 36.4 points.

What the numbers don’t tell us

The analysis re-sorts the partisan vote actually cast in 2026 onto other lines. It does not predict who would have won under a different map, for three reasons.

  • Different candidates. McAdams ran in a safe Salt Lake district and won about 70% of the vote. Under other maps, those voters would have been split among different districts, matchups and incumbents.

  • Different campaigns. Two or four competitive districts would have drawn different spending and attention from both parties than one safe seat did.

  • Different turnout. Voters in a lopsided district may behave differently than voters in a toss-up.

What the results do show is how much Utah’s delegation depends on where the lines fall. With the statewide House vote split almost evenly, the same ballots produce anywhere from one Democratic seat to two comfortable ones, depending on the map.

More from Utah Political Watch

Keep Reading