Sponsored by

How 2M+ Professionals Stay Ahead on AI

AI is moving fast and most people are falling behind. 

The Rundown AI keeps you ahead of the curve. 

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses — tailored to your needs.

The blue wave that swept the country on Election Day hit Utah hard. Democrats won the statewide vote for Congress, flipped legislative seats in districts Donald Trump carried easily in 2024 and sent Ben McAdams to Washington from the new Salt Lake County-based 1st District.

It also raises a question about the congressional map Republicans spent years and more than $1.1 million on outside lawyers defending in court. The 2021 lines split Salt Lake County four ways. How would those districts have performed in a year like this one?

A Utah Political Watch analysis of official precinct-level results puts the 2026 vote on those old lines. Democratic House candidates led in the old 1st and 2nd districts. Republicans held narrow leads in the 3rd and 4th. All four finished within three points, though Trump carried each by at least 18 points in 2024.

How big was the wave

The Democratic surge in Utah wasn't confined to Salt Lake County. It showed up almost everywhere at roughly the same size.

  • Congress: Democratic House candidates won 488,823 votes statewide to 483,042 for Republicans, 46.9% to 46.4%, in official county canvass results. McAdams won the new 1st District by about 45 points.

  • The Legislature: In the 74 legislative races with both a Republican and a Democrat on the ballot, the Republican ran behind Trump's 2024 share in 73, by a median of 7.7 points. Republicans lost or trail in 14 districts Trump carried, including seven he won with more than 55%. 

  • Safe seats: Even Republican strongholds moved. In seats rated safe Republican, the party ran an average of 6.8 points behind Trump. In toss-ups, it ran 10.2 points behind.

  • The ballot: Amendment B, which would have required 60% approval for citizen initiatives that raise taxes, failed with more than 60% voting no. Utah Supreme Court Justice Jill Pohlman, the target of a GOP campaign over the court’s redistricting ruling, was retained by better than 3-to-1.

That uniformity is what matters for the old map. Four districts built at roughly R+20 could not absorb a swing that large and that even.

Four toss-ups

The table combines the votes for every Democratic and every Republican congressional candidate on the ballot in each precinct.

2021 district

Democrats

Republicans

2026 margin

Trump 2024 margin

Shift toward Democrats

1st

47.9%

45.1%

D+2.8

R+19.5

22.3 pts

2nd

48.2%

45.2%

D+3.0

R+19.9

22.9 pts

3rd

46.3%

47.3%

R+1.0

R+18.7

17.7 pts

4th

45.3%

47.9%

R+2.6

R+26.1

23.5 pts

Statewide, Democratic House candidates received 488,823 votes to 483,042 for Republicans. That is a 0.6-point edge in a state Trump won by more than 20 points.

The swing was nearly uniform. The 1st, 2nd and 4th districts each moved 22 to 24 points toward Democrats. The 3rd moved the least, but it started closest to even and finished nearly tied.

Support Utah Political Watch
Readers like you keep this going.
Other amount

How the 2021 map cracked Salt Lake County

The 2021 map divided Salt Lake County, the state’s population center and Democratic base, among all four districts. Each district paired a slice of the county with a large, reliably Republican rural or suburban area. Critics said the design diluted Democratic votes, and it did: Republicans won all four seats by wide margins in 2022 and 2024.

The design depends on rural and suburban Republican margins swamping the county slices. When the whole state shifts at once, four districts built at roughly R+20 shift together. This year, that left all four within three points. A map meant to lock in four safe seats would have left Republicans defending four toss-ups.

The map never faced that test. Third District Judge Dianna Gibson ruled in August 2025 that it was unconstitutional because the Legislature had gutted Proposition 4, the voter-approved anti-gerrymandering initiative. On Nov. 10, 2025, she rejected the Legislature’s replacement map and adopted Map 1, drawn by the plaintiffs, the League of Women Voters of Utah and Mormon Women for Ethical Government. That map keeps most of Salt Lake County together in two districts instead of four.

Under the new lines, Democrat Ben McAdams won the 1st District by about 45 points. Republicans held the other three seats: Blake Moore by about 7 points, Mike Kennedy by 13 and Celeste Maloy by 21.

The new map gave Democrats one seat. The same votes on the old map would have put two within reach and made all four competitive.

What the analysis can’t show

This is not a claim that Democrats would have won two seats under the old map. The analysis re-sorts the partisan vote actually cast this year onto the old lines, and real campaigns would have played out differently.

McAdams won roughly 70% in a deep-blue Salt Lake district. Under the 2021 map, those voters would have been split four ways, most of them facing a Republican incumbent rather than an open seat. Four competitive districts would also have drawn far more money and attention from both parties than one safe seat and three Republican-leaning ones, and turnout tends to follow competition.

What the numbers do show is that voters in every old district split almost evenly in a wave year.

Keep Reading